skip to content
 
mathematical knitted models

These knitted models (Image 1) illustrate the abstract mathematical surfaces that their creator, the Scottish chemist Alexander Crum Brown (1838-1922), describes in an 1885 paper for the Royal Society of Edinburgh.

Visual Aid or Research Tool?

mathematical knitted model showing interpenetrating surfaces (aka topology of interlacing surfaces), by Alexander Crum Brown, Scottish, 1885
Image 1: mathematical knitted model showing interpenetrating surfaces, by Alexander Crum Brown, Scottish, 1885 (Wh.4470)

These objects are two of the many (at least seventeen) models Crum Brown constructed following the discussion in his paper, 'On a Case of Interlacing Surfaces' (1). That paper explores the behaviour of perforated surfaces like those depicted in Image 3. Crum Brown refers directly to 'the models exhibited', indicating that he had some models with him when he presented the paper to the Royal Society of Edinburgh.

Wh.4469, mathematical knitted model showing interpenetrating surfaces (aka topology of interlacing surfaces), by Alexander Crum Brown, Scottish, 1885
Image 2: Wh.4469

However, the models we have today don't perfectly match the descriptions in the paper. It seems likely that making these models was part of how Crum Brown researched surfaces of this kind, rather than merely a way to explain his work to others.

A Theory to Tie Everything Together

Illustration of three interlacing surfaces
Image 3: Illustration of three interlacing surfaces from Crum Brown's 'On a Case of Interlacing Surfaces' (page 382)

Though these models accompany a mathematical paper, Crum Brown's reputation is undoubtedly as a chemist. He never wrote about his knitted surfaces in relation to chemistry, but he worked at a time when many scientists would have seen his study of surfaces as highly relevant to the physical sciences.

In 1867, the physicist William Thomson hypothesized that atoms might be tiny knotted tubes of a perfect fluid called 'ether'. He hoped this hypothesis would reconcile a seeming contradiction between fluid dynamics, which assumed matter to be continuous, and chemistry, which theorised discrete pieces of matter called atoms. Thomson intended to explain the existence of different atoms in terms of different knots; thus knot theory, the mathematical classification of knots, was born. Thomson's idea, known as the vortex-atom hypothesis, has long since been rejected, but knot theory remains a vibrant area of research today.

Crum Brown never wrote about the vortex-atom hypothesis himself, but he was close with its most enthusiastic supporters. We cannot know whether he shared his colleagues' optimism that the study of knots would illuminate the fundamental nature of matter. But in this context it is no stretch to see Crum Brown's study of interlacing surfaces as part of his scientific work. By knitting these strange, colourful objects, Crum Brown was exploring the ways surfaces can intertwine and - he might reasonably have hoped - the way atoms hold together.

References

  1. Alexander Crum Brown. 'On a Case of Interlacing Surfaces'. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh volume 13 (1885-6), pp. 382-386.

David Dunning

David Dunning, 'Knitted Interpenetrating Surfaces', Explore Whipple Collections, Whipple Museum of the History of Science, University of Cambridge, 2014.

Next Article: Modelling Chemistry

Opening Times

We will be closed on Monday 16th December .

We will be closed on 21st December and will remain closed through the holiday period. We will re-open on 9th January.

We are regularly open five days a week, 12.30 - 16:30.

And now open the third Saturday of every month!

Monday 12.30 - 16:30

Tuesday 12.30 - 16:30

Wednesday 12.30 - 16:30

Thursday 12.30 - 16:30

Friday 12.30 - 16:30

Selected Saturdays 10.00 - 16.00

We hope to see you soon!